Beautiful Seneca Lakefront
Over 160′ of beautiful Seneca Lake waterfront with each cottage includes a dedicated boat slip to store your watercraft.
Stylish and Contemporary Interiors
These newly built homes have stylish and contemporary interiors.
Over 100 Finger Lakes Wineries
Plum Point is directly on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail with over 100 wineries in the region and more than half of those on Seneca Lake.
Great Curb Appeal
Newly constructed homes with attached patio and professionally maintained landscaping, these homes have great curb appeal.
Welcome to our community!
Located on the western shore of Seneca Lake, the Cottages at Plum Point offer the perfect location for any getaway. The Cottages are directly on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, next door to some of the best restaurants in the area, and a private lake front park with a boat slip with each cottage.
At 35 miles long, Seneca Lake is the largest of the Finger Lakes. It is also deep! The lake is over 600 feet deep. The lake is also known as the Lake Trout capital of the country and hosts an annual Lake Trout Derby.
Cottages at Plum Point
Welcome to your dream lake community! Nestled on the picturesque west shore of Seneca Lake, our beautiful cottages offer the perfect carefree lake-living experience. Our affordable community boasts over 160′ of beautiful Seneca Lake waterfront with each cottage including a dedicated boat slip to store your watercraft — serving as the perfect launching point for your adventures throughout the renowned 67 sq/mi Finger Lake! Development began in 2020 and 29 units are planned to be built over the course of 6 years.
Meet Cathy Shelanskey and Calvin Ruthven! They have lived in the Finger Lakes all their life and have served the community as real estate agents collectively for almost twenty years.
The property is located on Plum Point Road and Ulster Road between State Route 14 and Seneca Lake. Our goal is to add 5 to 6 properties a year until we reach our goal of 29 units. To see the latest listings, please check as we update this site periodically.